A woman accused of killing two teenagers while driving drunk is back in the Dane County Jail after briefly being held in an immigration detention facility.
Noelia Martinez-Avila was charged with multiple felony counts of homicide by intoxicated use of a vehicle after she was involved in a crash on July 20, which resulted in the deaths of two Minnesota teens.
Martinez-Avila became the center of a custody battle between the Dane County Sheriff’s Office and U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, which said she is from Honduras and in the U.S. illegally. On July 22, Dane County Sheriff Kalvin Barrett denied an ICE detainer request, which prompted ICE Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin to accuse Dane County of being a “sanctuary jurisdiction.”
At the time, a statement from Barrett said deporting someone before they face trial “allows them to evade accountability — it’s essentially a ‘get out of jail free’ card.”
News with a little more humanity
WPR’s “Wisconsin Today” newsletter keeps you connected to the state you love without feeling overwhelmed. No paywall. No agenda. No corporate filter.
On Aug. 13, the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel reported that Martinez-Avila’s attorney posted a $250,000 bond and she was released from the Dane County Jail and arrested by ICE. Another release from the federal agency said the sheriff’s office gave ICE “less than an hour to make the arrest” but agents “nabbed” Martinez-Avila just the same.
The ICE arrest was made possible, in part, because the Dane County Sheriff’s Office notified agents of her pending release, according to a spokesperson for the department. In a statement sent after the ICE arrest, Barrett said it was part of standard “policies and procedures.”
“I stand by my previous statements regarding crime victims deserving their opportunity for justice,” Barrett said. “Still, I am fully aware that, as Sheriff, certain aspects of the justice system are beyond my control.”
Following the ICE arrest, Martinez-Avila was moved to the Waukesha County Jail, which serves as an ICE detention center. That led to a flurry of motions from prosecutors in the criminal case to raise her bail in order to get her back to Dane County. An emergency motion filed by Assistant Dane County District Attorney Alexandra Keyes said Martinez-Avila was facing “deportation in the immediate future.”
“In order to hold her accountable for these crimes against her and comply with victim’s rights, the State is requesting an emergency order either revoking the defendant’s bail or an order to return her to our jurisdiction,” Keyes said.
The motion also claimed Martinez-Avila was in violation of her original bail conditions because the Dane County Sheriff’s Office released her without placing a GPS and alcohol monitor on her. The sheriff’s office denied that claim and said it’s common for GPS monitors to not be placed on defendants when they’re taken directly to another jail.
On Friday, Judge Diane Schlipper raised Martinez-Avila’s bail to $5 million and ordered her to be brought back to the Dane County Jail, where she currently resides. A Dane County Sheriff’s Office spokesperson said it was Waukesha County sheriff’s deputies who returned Martinez-Avila, who signed the modified bail agreement Monday.
Neither Barrett nor ICE officials have commented on Martinez-Avila’s return to the Dane County Jail.
Wisconsin Public Radio, © Copyright 2025, Board of Regents of the University of Wisconsin System and Wisconsin Educational Communications Board.
