The Complex Minds Of Carnivores

Air Date:
Heard On The Larry Meiller Show
Orcas breaching

When we think about carnivores, most of us think of them as unthinking killing machines. Our guest has a different viewpoint. We talk to her about the science behind her ideas and about her new book.

Featured in this Show

  • Author: Misconception Of Carnivores As Killing Machines Clouds True Nature Of Animals

    From the fairy tales we grew up with to the movies that terrify us, humans have been casting carnivores in the role of unthinking killing machines for hundreds of years.

    The author of a new book on how carnivore minds work says these misconceptions hide the true nature of these animals.

    “The stereotype that people have about these species is really completely far from the truth, the scientific data and experience,” said Gay Bradshaw, a psychologist and ecologist and author of the book “Carnivore Minds: Who These Fearsome Animals Really Are.”

    Using sharks as an example, she cites a statistic claiming three fatal shark attacks were reported worldwide in 2014; that same year, 1.24 million vehicular deaths occurred worldwide in 2014.

    The damage inflicted by these animals is blown out of proportion, Bradshaw said, especially when compared to the harm inflicted by family pets or even falls in homes.

    “There’s a huge exaggeration between myth and actual fact,” she said.

    Animals considered predators, carnivores or pests are often grouped together, not for a single reason but because of motives that have more to do with human attitudes and psychology than facts or biology, Bradshaw said.

    Scientists are increasingly challenging these long-held beliefs about carnivores, she said. Research is showing these animals are closer to us psychologically than we thought possible, and individual personalities within a species vary as much as our own

    Through research for her book, Bradshaw discovered great white sharks express tender maternal feelings, rattlesnakes make friends and orcas follow a moral code.

    Not only do these animals have feelings of community, feel loss and nurture their young, but they know fear and stress. Bradshaw said she believes many animals are suffering from a form of post-traumatic stress disorder brought on by the years of stress related to hunting and loss of habitat.

    This has resulted in animals that are no longer acting as their ancestors did, she said. For example, there are reports of young pumas moving into cities and suburbs, and teenage dolphins killing porpoises — all abnormal behavior, Bradshaw said. The most likely cause of the unusual behavior is psychological trauma.

    “Changes on the outside — mass killings, loss of habitat and adequate prey, perennial lethal pursuit — eventually leave their traces on the inside,” she said. “Even the fiercest creature has limits.”

    Bradshaw said she believes we need to replace old fashioned ideas of carnivores with a new more ethical approach. One that will help us coexist.

Episode Credits

  • Larry Meiller Host
  • Jill Nadeau Producer
  • Gay A Bradshaw Guest

Related Stories